The short answer is usually yes, but there are real limits. A practical overview of what applies where, and when to leave something in place.
The shell and gravel beds at low tide. Loose finds here are what most visitors take home.
Most of what people pick up at Shark Tooth Island (small fossil shark teeth, shell, weathered fragments) is casual personal collecting of common surface finds. For that, on the kinds of publicly accessible dredge-spoil shoreline the island sits on, the answer is usually yes.
But "usually yes" is not "always yes." A few distinctions matter.
Great white
Mako
Bull shark
Tiger shark
Usually fine to keep: loose fossil teeth like these, picked up off the shoreline. Not sure what you found? Try Tooth ID.
Note. This page is a practical orientation, not legal advice. Laws, jurisdictions, and site-specific rules change. Before collecting anything beyond casual surface finds, and especially before collecting at scale or for resale, confirm the current rules with the relevant agency.
The Short Answer by Scenario
check
Casual personal collecting of common surface finds
Picking up loose fossil shark teeth, shell, and common surface material on publicly accessible dredge-spoil shoreline is generally permitted. The NC Museum of Natural Sciences says no permit is currently required to collect fossils on state or municipal public land, and that loose shark teeth can generally be collected. This is what most visitors do.
help
Unusual, large, or clearly significant finds
If you find something that looks scientifically significant (articulated bone, a near-complete jaw, a very large or unusual specimen), photograph it, note the location, and contact a local museum or university. Significant finds may fall under different rules than casual surface material.
help
Vertebrate fossils on federal land
Under the Paleontological Resources Preservation Act (PRPA), vertebrate fossils on federal land are protected. If any part of a site is federally administered, the rules change. Fossil shark teeth are vertebrate material. When in doubt, check jurisdiction.
close
Commercial collecting and resale
Commercial-scale collection, mechanized digging, or collecting for resale is governed by separate rules and typically requires permits. It's not what this site covers. Personal keepsakes and a handful of teeth per trip is not the same thing as commercial extraction.
close
Digging, excavating, or disturbing the shoreline
Even on sites where collecting surface finds is fine, digging pits, excavating banks, or otherwise disturbing the landform is a different category. Surface collection, not excavation, is the norm for casual visits.
close
Man-made artifacts (pottery, glass, metal, projectile points)
Human-made objects at least 50 years old on state-owned land are archaeological resources under the North Carolina Archaeological Resources Protection Act (NCGS Chapter 70, Article 2). Taking, damaging, or selling them without a state permit is illegal. If you find something man-made and old, photograph it, note the location, leave it, and report it to the NC Office of State Archaeology.
Important clarification: The Act expressly states that paleontological specimens are not archaeological resources unless they're found in an archaeological context (NCGS 70-12(2)). Loose fossil shark teeth, shells, and similar natural finds usually aren't covered. That's why casual fossil collecting on spoil-island shoreline is generally fine.
Shark Tooth Island Specifically
Shark Tooth Island, a dredge-spoil island in the Cape Fear River.
Shark Tooth Island is associated with the chain of dredge-spoil islands in the lower Cape Fear River. That's context that matters: personal collecting of common fossil material on publicly accessible spoil-island shoreline is generally permitted in the Cape Fear region. One open question is whether the island sits under a federal dredge-disposal easement, which could change the rules. The agencies below can confirm.
That said, the lower Cape Fear is a working river with multiple agencies involved in its management. Jurisdiction and access can change. For site-specific current guidance, check with:
When in doubt, photograph it, note the location, leave it in place.
That approach handles every scenario above. You haven't broken any rule, you have a record if someone wants to study the find, and you can ask later.
What "Leave It Right" Actually Means
Legality is the floor, not the ceiling. Even where collecting is permitted, a few practices make the difference between visitors the island welcomes back and visitors who degrade the site for the people who come after them.
Pack out everything you bring in. Including food scraps, water bottles, bag tags, gear wrappers. The tide cleans up some of it. Most of it just stays.
Don't dig into the banks. The tide does the digging and sorts the loose material for you. Digging pits or prying at the banks undercuts the shoreline and changes the way the island reworks itself.
Respect wildlife. Seabirds nest on spoil islands in parts of the lower Cape Fear. Fiddler crabs, shorebirds, and occasional alligators are present. Don't approach or disturb nesting areas. Keep dogs leashed or left at home.
Hunt by hand. Keep the loose teeth you find. That's what the trip is for. Shovels and mechanized digging are a different thing: they tear up the shoreline, and commercial-scale collecting or collecting for resale needs permits.
If you find something significant, share it. Museums, university geology departments, and state paleontologists are genuinely interested in unusual finds. A clear photo and a location note is all it takes.
When to Leave It in Place
There are specific things that should stay where you found them:
•Articulated skeletal material. Bone pieces that clearly belong together. Pulling them apart destroys the scientific context.
•A near-complete jaw or skeleton. Anything that feels like a museum piece probably should go through one.
•Bone, artifacts or anything unusual you can't identify. Document it and leave it. A loose, ordinary-looking find you're unsure about is fine to keep and ask about later.
These aren't hard legal rules for every single case. They're the ethics the site rewards. You get more trips, better finds, and a clearer conscience if you operate this way.
STI
SharkToothIsland.org
By Mozy Outdoors · An independent guide · Cape Fear Region, NC