The island in the lower Cape Fear River near Wilmington is called Shark Tooth Island. You'll also see Sharks Tooth Island and Shark's Tooth Island, including in local news coverage. They all mean the same small island across from River Road Park.
The name is descriptive and it fits: go at low tide, work the exposed shoreline, find teeth. Megalodon, great white, tiger, bull, mako. The sediments here have been producing them for as long as people have been paddling out to look.
Virginia has one too.
Virginia's Shark Tooth Island, also called Hollis Island, is a sandbar on the Potomac River near Montross, about 290 miles north of here in a straight line. Different island, different river, different state.
The two names are easy to conflate in a search. They aren't the same place.
If you're looking for the Cape Fear River location (the one near Wilmington, reached by kayak or small boat), you're on the right site. Shark Tooth Island. Everything here is about that place: how to get there, when to go, what to look for, and how the island came to be.
If you're looking for the Potomac River site in Virginia, this site won't be much help. It's a different island, and it's out of our coverage area.
Either way: the names belong to different islands, different rivers, different states. Getting them right is the first step to finding the right place.